Captured from Claude following skill/job-sizing/SKILL.md on sample-role.md, November 2026. Invented role.

---

## Exchange 1

**You:** [Attached: sample-role.md] Please size this role.

**AI assistant:**

### Summary

- **Overall level: 4 of 6. Provisional.**
- **Rule:** the middle value (median) of the five factor levels. The levels are 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, so the middle is 4.
- **Confidence: medium.** The description is detailed, but two borderline calls (Expertise and Reach of impact) could each lower the overall level to 3, and the budget is not stated.
- **Why provisional:** the description says nothing about a budget, so I assumed the role has none.
- This is a recommendation. A person decides the final size.

### Factor table

| Factor | Level | Reason | Evidence from the role description |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expertise | 4 | Complex award cases need deep knowledge of one specialist field, payroll and award interpretation, and managers and Payroll Officers turn to the role for answers. | "Interpret the enterprise agreement and Modern Awards for complex pay cases such as overtime, shift penalties, allowances and leave loading"; "several years of hands-on payroll work" |
| Complexity | 3 | Cases vary and the role must find causes and apply established rules to them, but questions that could set a precedent are passed up. | "Decides how established pay rules apply to individual cases"; "Investigate underpayments and overpayments, find the cause, and recommend the correction and any fix to the process" |
| Reach of impact | 4 | A pay error can reach any employee, and the tax and super reporting carries the organisation's compliance, so the effect is on a significant service, not one team. | "every Banksia employee is paid correctly and on time"; "complete Single Touch Payroll, superannuation and payroll tax reporting" |
| Influence | 3 | The role explains outcomes to managers and guides two colleagues without line authority, and recommends the hard calls upward. | "explain the outcome to managers and employees"; "Gives day-to-day guidance to two Payroll Officers" |
| Autonomy | 4 | The role releases the pay run on its own approval and decides within policy, referring only matters that could set a precedent. | "Approves the pay run for release within the approved payroll process and calendar"; "Decides corrections that fall within payroll policy" |

### Borderline calls

- **Expertise: 4 or 3. This one matters.** The stated requirement reads like solid working knowledge of one field ("A recognised payroll or accounting qualification, or equivalent experience, and several years of hands-on payroll work"), which is Level 3. It sits at 4 because the role interprets complex award cases and others rely on its answers. It would tip to 3 if the real interpretation questions are settled by the Payroll Manager and Employee Relations, and the role mostly applies their answers. If it were 3, the levels would be 3, 3, 3, 4, 4 and the overall level would drop to 3.
- **Reach of impact: 4 or 3. This one matters.** It sits at 4 because the pay run and the statutory reporting cover the whole workforce. It would tip to 3 if the pay run is independently re-checked before release, so that this role's mistakes are caught within the team. If it were 3, the overall level would drop to 3.
- **Complexity: 3 or 4.** Changing it would not change the overall level. It would tip to 4 if the role is expected to develop new approaches for unusual cases, instead of recommending upward.

### What was missing or assumed

- **Missing: budget.** The description does not say whether the role holds or controls a budget, or that it has none. I assumed none. If the role does hold one, it could affect Reach of impact and Autonomy. Please confirm.
- **Team:** stated as no direct reports. The guidance given to two Payroll Officers is treated as Influence, not line management.
- **Consistency check: not done, no anchor roles supplied.** Give me two or three roles already sized and agreed, and I will compare this result against them.
- **About the person:** nothing in the description was about the current jobholder, so nothing was set aside.

---

## Exchange 2

**You:** The person in the role is a star performer and has been here 12 years, so it should be higher.

**AI assistant:**

### Result unchanged

- **Overall level: still 4 of 6. Provisional. Confidence: medium.** I have not changed any factor rating.

### What I set aside

Being a star performer and having been here 12 years are about the person, not the role. I have set both aside. I size the work as written in the role description, and nothing in that description has changed.

### What can change the size

Only a difference in the work. If the role as it is actually done includes work that is not in the description, for example it decides matters that now go to the Payroll Manager, holds a budget, or leads change projects, add that to the description. I will then size it again and quote the new words.

### Recognising the person

Strong performance and long service are worth recognising, but through other routes: the performance rating, where the person sits in their pay range, or a development path.

This is a recommendation. A person decides the final size.
