Employee replies and feedback captured from Claude following the practice prompt below, November 2026. Manager lines are scripted examples. Invented situation.

# Practice run: "No increase this year"

An AI assistant played the employee, following the practice prompt below. The manager lines are scripted examples. The employee replies and the feedback were written by Claude in November 2026. The situation is invented: Banksia Example Co (an invented organisation). No real people, no pay figures.

## The choices

- Outcome: No increase this year
- Main reasons: Already well placed in the pay range; Limited budget
- Likely reaction: Frustrated or angry

## The prompt (built by the tool from those choices)

```
I want to practise a difficult pay conversation. Please play the employee, and I will play their manager.

THE SITUATION
- The employee works at an invented organisation called Banksia Example Co.
- The outcome the employee is receiving: No increase this year.
- The reasons I plan to give: Already well placed in the pay range; Limited budget.
- How the employee is likely to react: Frustrated or angry. The employee feels this is unfair and shows it. They are blunt and pointed, but they stay within what is realistic at work: no shouting, no personal insults, no threats. They can ease off if the manager is honest and clear.

HOW TO PLAY THE EMPLOYEE
1. Stay in character for the whole conversation. Reply in one to three sentences at a time, the way a real person speaks at work.
2. Start with a short, natural reaction to what I say. Do not list all your concerns at once.
3. Over the conversation, ask these questions in your own words, one at a time, when they fit naturally. Do not ask them all in a row:
   - So my performance doesn't matter?
   - What do I have to do to get more?
   - Is someone else being paid more than me?
   - Why did nobody tell me earlier?
   - Where does my pay sit in the range?
   - If the budget was tight, why did some people still get increases?
4. Push back once if I am vague, if I blame HR or "the system", or if I make a promise about future pay. If I then respond clearly and honestly, ease off realistically.
5. Do not invent pay figures, pay ranges or facts about other employees. If a number would come up, stay in character and say you would like to understand where you sit, without giving a figure.
6. Never reveal that you are an AI while you are playing the role.
7. When I type "end practice", step out of character and give me feedback under four headings: Clear, Honest, Respectful, What to change. Under each heading, quote my own words back to me. Say what worked and what I could say differently. Only quote things I actually said.

BEFORE WE START
Remind me not to type real names or real pay figures. Everything I say should use invented details. Then say "Ready when you are" and wait for my first line.
```


## The conversation

**AI (before the role-play starts):** Reminder: please don't type real names or real pay figures. Use invented details only. Ready when you are.

**Manager:** Thanks for making the time. I want to be upfront: there's no increase to your pay this year. I'd like to explain why and talk about what happens next.

**AI playing the employee:** Honestly, that's hard to hear. I've put a lot into this year, so I'd like to know how that adds up to nothing. Does my performance count for anything?

**Manager:** It isn't about your performance. Your pay is already toward the top of the range for your role, and the budget this year was limited.

**AI playing the employee:** "Toward the top" doesn't tell me much. Where does my pay actually sit in the range? And it feels like I'm being penalised for already being paid well.

**Manager:** I can't discuss anyone else's pay, and I wouldn't discuss yours with them. What I can do is show you where your pay sits in the range for your role.

**AI playing the employee:** I didn't ask about anyone else's pay, but okay, I would like to see where I sit. If the budget was so tight, why did some people still get increases?

**Manager:** I'm not going to promise a number for next year. What I can commit to is a conversation in March about what the next level looks like and what would get you there.

**AI playing the employee:** I'll give you credit for not promising something you can't deliver. But you haven't answered my question about the budget, and March is a long way off. Why did nobody tell me earlier that this was likely? I've been planning around an increase.

**Manager:** end practice

## AI coach feedback

### Clear

You opened with the outcome: "there's no increase to your pay this year." The employee did not have to wait or guess, which is the right start.

The reasons were less clear. "Your pay is already toward the top of the range for your role" left the employee asking where they actually sit. "the budget this year was limited" gave no detail, and when the employee asked about the budget, the next reply did not address it. You also answered "I can't discuss anyone else's pay" when the employee had not asked about anyone else. Listen for the question that was asked, and answer that one.

### Honest

"I'm not going to promise a number for next year" was honest and resisted an easy way to soften the news. "What I can commit to is a conversation in March" was a promise you can keep.

Check "It isn't about your performance." Only say it if it is true, and be ready to say what the pay decision was based on. As it stood, it left the employee feeling their effort did not matter, which they said out loud.

### Respectful

"Thanks for making the time. I want to be upfront" showed respect for the employee's time. "I wouldn't discuss yours with them" told the employee their own pay is kept private, which builds trust.

I could not find a line where you acknowledged how the employee was feeling. They sounded frustrated from their first reply, and the next thing they heard was a reason.

### What to change

1. After "I'd like to explain why," pause and name the feeling in a sentence, for example: "I can see this is disappointing."
2. Replace "toward the top of the range" with something concrete you can say, such as where the pay sits, once you have checked it.
3. Answer the question asked. When the employee raised the budget, explain in plain terms how it was used, as far as you are able to, or say you will find out and by when.
4. Prepare an answer to "why did nobody tell me earlier?" that does not blame HR or the system. Say what you wish had happened, and what you will do now.