← All use cases
Use case 04

Manager pay conversation coach

Talking points, tough questions and a practice run before the real conversation, so managers can explain a pay outcome clearly and honestly.

Vibe-coded tool Prep works offline Practice uses your approved AI
Try itUse the real tool. Watch itFive steps, animated. Build itPrompts you can paste. Check the dataWhat is safe, and where. Take itDownload the finished file.

What it does and why it matters

A pay outcome explained badly does more damage than the outcome itself. Managers blame HR, over-promise, or freeze when someone pushes back. Reward teams cannot sit in every conversation. This tool puts good preparation in every manager's hands.

It has two halves. The prep builder is ordinary code. The manager picks the outcome, the main reasons and how the employee is likely to react, and gets talking points, likely tough questions and what not to say. The same choices give the same output every time. The practice partner is a ready-to-paste prompt that makes the manager's own approved AI assistant play the employee, then give feedback.

The benefit is fewer escalations landing back on the reward team, and managers who sound like they understand the decision.

1Try it

This is the real prep builder, running in your browser. Pick an outcome, up to three reasons and a likely reaction, then press Build my prep.

Nothing you choose is saved or sent anywhere.

Hear a practice run

This is what the practice prompt does in an AI assistant. The employee is frustrated. The manager lines are scripted. Press Play to watch it, or Show all to read it.

Replay Employee replies and feedback captured from Claude, November 2026. Manager lines are scripted examples. Invented situation.

The practice itself happens in your own approved AI assistant, not on this site.

2Watch it

Five steps from a pay outcome to a rehearsed conversation. Press Play, or step through at your own pace.

Step 1 of 5Invented example
Outcome (pick one)
Pay increase in line with expectations Smaller increase than hoped No increase this year Bonus below target
Main reasons (up to three)
Already well placed in the pay range Performance this year Limited budget Market movement for the role
How they are likely to react (pick one)
Disappointed but calm Frustrated or angry Confused about how it works Quiet, hard to read

Pick the situation. Three choices, no typing. No names and no pay figures, so there is nothing sensitive to enter.

OpenThere's no increase to your pay this year. I'd like to explain why and talk about what happens next.
The decisionYour pay stays where it is after this review. This is the decision for this review cycle.
The whyYour pay is already well placed in the range for your role. The budget this year was limited.
What happens nextThe next pay review is in [month]. I can't tell you what it will decide, and I won't guess. Can we talk again in a week or two?

Talking points you can say aloud. Four parts: say the outcome first, explain the decision, give the reasons one at a time, then say what happens next.

So my performance doesn't matter?
What do I have to do to get more?
Is someone else being paid more than me?
Suggested answerI can't talk about anyone else's pay, and I wouldn't discuss yours with them either. I can show you where your pay sits in the range for your role.
Why did nobody tell me earlier?

The questions you are dreading. The tool lists the questions this employee is likely to ask, with a suggested answer and the trap to avoid for each.

Instead ofHR won't let me.
TryThis was decided through our pay review process. Here is how it works and what it means for you.
Instead ofI fought for you, but...
TryI took your case seriously. The decision is no increase this year, and here is why.

What not to say. Common lines that backfire, each with a better alternative and the reason.

AI playing the employeeNo increase at all? So does my performance actually matter?
ManagerI can see this is hard to hear. Your performance isn't the reason. Your pay is already well placed in the range, and the budget was limited.
AI coach feedback
Clear
You gave the reasons in plain words.
Honest
You did not promise anything about next year.
Respectful
You named how they were feeling.
What to change
Say what the pay range is before you say where they sit in it.

Rehearse it. Paste the practice prompt into your approved AI assistant. It plays the employee, then steps out and gives feedback quoting your own words.

Everything in this walkthrough is an invented example, for illustration only.

3Build it

You can build your own version with any capable AI assistant your employer allows, for example Microsoft Copilot, Claude or ChatGPT. You describe what you want, it writes the code, and you check the result.

The tool you build contains no AI. The wording is yours, so the most important step is the second one: giving the tool your organisation's own words, then having your reward lead review every line.

Step 1: Describe the tool

Say what the tool is, what goes in, what comes out, and who will use it.

I work in HR in Australia and I am not a developer. Please build me a manager pay conversation prep tool as a single HTML file that I can save to my computer and open in a browser by double-clicking it. Requirements: - It must run offline. Use no external libraries, images or links, and send no data anywhere. Do not save anything. - Use choices only. There must be no free-text fields, so nobody can type a name or a pay figure. Show this line near the top: "No names or pay figures needed. Nothing you choose here is saved or sent anywhere." - There are three inputs: 1. The outcome (pick one): Pay increase in line with expectations; Smaller increase than hoped; No increase this year; Bonus at or above target; Bonus below target; No bonus; Promotion without the pay rise hoped for; Out-of-cycle pay request declined. 2. The main reasons (pick up to three): Already well placed in the pay range; Performance this year; Limited budget; Market movement for the role; Fairness with others in similar roles; Short time in role; A policy rule (for example eligibility dates). 3. How the employee is likely to react (pick one): Disappointed but calm; Frustrated or angry; Confused about how it works; Quiet, hard to read; Pleased. - There are four tabs of output: Talking points, Tough questions, What not to say, Practice prompt. - The tool is ordinary code. The same choices must always give the same output. Do not call any AI from inside the tool. - Put all the wording in one data object at the top of the script, with plain-English comments, so I can edit the wording without touching the code. - Add a Print or save as PDF button. Use plain English and Australian spelling. Before you write any code, tell me in a few sentences what you plan to build, and ask me about anything that is unclear.

Step 2: Give it your organisation's wording

The AI does not know your pay review process. Let it interview you, then write the content from your answers.

Now I want the tool to use my organisation's own wording. Do not write the content yet. First, interview me, one question at a time, about: - How our pay review works: when it happens, who decides, what a manager is allowed to say, and what a manager must never say. - The reasons we really use for pay outcomes, and how we describe each one in plain words. - Our house rules: whether managers can share where someone sits in the pay range, how we handle eligibility dates, and what we say about the next review. - Where a manager should go when an employee asks something the manager cannot answer. Use invented examples only. Do not ask me for real names or real pay figures, and if I type any, tell me to remove them. When you have enough, write the full content library into the data object at the top of the file. For each outcome, include: an opening sentence, a plain-words description of the decision, what the employee can influence, and what happens next. For each reason, include a short paragraph a manager can say aloud. Write five or six tough questions with a suggested answer and one trap to avoid, and eight lines managers should not say with a better alternative and the reason. Rules for every line you write: - Say it so a manager can say it aloud. - Never promise or hint at future pay. - Never disclose or compare another person's pay. - Never mislead the employee. - Put anything the manager must fill in, such as a date, in [square brackets]. Then list every line that depends on a policy fact I gave you, so my reward lead can check each one.

Have your reward lead review every line before any manager sees it. The AI can write the wording. It cannot know whether the wording matches your policy.

Step 3: Add the practice prompt

The fourth tab writes a prompt for the manager's own AI assistant. Be exact about what that prompt must make the assistant do.

Now add the fourth tab, "Practice prompt". It builds a complete prompt from the three choices, shown in a dark block with a Copy button. Above the block, show this line: "Paste this into your approved AI assistant. Practise out loud if you can." The prompt it writes must tell the AI assistant to: 1. Play an employee at an invented organisation called Banksia Example Co, who is receiving the chosen outcome, with the chosen likely reaction. 2. Stay in character and reply in one to three sentences at a time. 3. Ask the tough questions for this situation naturally, one at a time, and not all in a row. 4. Push back once if the manager is vague, blames HR, or makes a promise about future pay. 5. Never reveal that it is an AI while it is playing the role. 6. When the manager types "end practice", step out of character and give feedback under four headings: Clear, Honest, Respectful, What to change. Quote the manager's own words under each heading, and only words the manager actually said. 7. Not invent pay figures, and remind the manager not to type real names or real pay figures. The same choices must always build the same prompt.

Step 4: Test it on a hard case

Test the hardest situation first. Then read every line aloud.

Please help me test the tool on a hard case. 1. Set the choices to the hardest situation: "No increase this year", with the reasons "Already well placed in the pay range" and "Limited budget", and the reaction "Frustrated or angry". Show me everything the tool produces for those choices. 2. Check each line against these rules, and tell me plainly about any line that breaks one: it must not promise or hint at future pay, mislead, blame HR or the system, compare people, or disclose anyone else's pay. 3. Point out any line that would sound odd or stiff if a manager said it aloud, and offer a more natural version. 4. List any line that depends on a fact only my organisation knows, so I can have it checked. 5. Then repeat the check for one good-news outcome and one calm, quiet employee. If you find a problem, say so. Do not defend the wording.

Then do the real test yourself. Read every line aloud, and remove anything a manager should not say.

Good habits

  • Have your reward lead approve every line before managers see the tool.
  • Read the wording aloud. If it sounds odd out loud, rewrite it.
  • Practise with the situation, never the person. No names and no real pay figures, in the tool or in the AI chat.
  • Keep the prompts you used, so you can update the wording when your policy changes.

4Check the data

What this touches

The prep builder touches nothing sensitive. It takes choices only, with no names and no figures. The practice run is where the risk is, because managers are tempted to type the real person's details to make the practice feel real.

What is safe

Practise with the situation, not the person. Leave out names, real pay figures, and health or personal circumstances. Use only an AI assistant your employer has approved.

Ask before you start

  • Which AI assistant are managers allowed to use?
  • Has the reward lead approved the wording?
  • Where do managers go when the employee asks something off-script?

Privacy rules for employee records differ between private employers and government agencies, so check with your privacy officer. Start with the OAIC's guidance on the Australian Privacy Principles and on employment and privacy. General information, not legal advice.

5Take it

Download the tool Open it in a new tab

It is a single file. Save it anywhere and double-click to open it. Before you share it with managers, edit the wording to match your organisation's policy and have your reward lead review it. The captured practice run is here: practice-transcript.md.

What next: Back to all use cases